GoHotelly
Hotel Check-in 15:00 · Check-out 11:00

Best Western Plus Brooklyn-Prospect Park

3.2-star hotel near Prospect Park offering free Wi-Fi, breakfast, and a smoke-free environment. Close to Brooklyn Museum, Botanic Garden, and Brooklyn Bridge.

928 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11230, United States View on map
6.4/10
Average Based on 43 recent guest reviews
Free Wi-Fi Breakfast Golf course Smoke-free
What recent guests emphasize

Balanced comfort and helpful service in a convenient Brooklyn location

Guests appreciate clean, well-maintained rooms and attentive staff, though some note noise from neighboring rooms. The hotel offers good value with included breakfast and a safe, residential area setting near popular Brooklyn attractions.

Guests often praise

  • Friendly, accommodating, and professional front desk staff providing helpful service
  • Clean, comfortable rooms with maintained furnishings and suitable temperature control
  • Complimentary breakfast that is well-prepared and satisfactory for guests
  • Safe neighborhood and convenient access to public transportation
  • Quiet atmosphere inside rooms despite the urban location

Worth knowing

  • Parking is limited and off-street, with no dedicated hotel parking available
  • Walls are thin, and some guests reported noise disturbances from neighboring rooms
  • No on-site restaurant or pool facilities
  • Some occasional noise from other guests, which may impact light sleepers
  • Free Wi-Fi is available, and the property is smoke-free

Best for

  • Budget-conscious travelers seeking clean accommodations in Brooklyn
  • Visitors planning to explore nearby attractions like Brooklyn Museum and Brooklyn Botanic Garden
  • Guests who value friendly, attentive service and a safe neighborhood
  • Travelers needing a comfortable base with free breakfast included
  • Those using public transport to access the city, with a 5-minute walk to the metro
Compare booking partners

Open this hotel on the platform you trust.

GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.

Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

About this property

Welcome to Best Western Plus Brooklyn-Prospect Park

Best Western Plus Brooklyn-Prospect Park is a modest, 3-star hotel situated in a diverse, residential area of Brooklyn known for its brick row houses and Victorian homes. The neighborhood boasts a variety of laid-back global restaurants, making it suitable for visitors seeking a quieter, local experience outside the typical tourist zones. The property offers free Wi-Fi and a complimentary breakfast, contributing to a convenient stay without on-site dining or parking facilities.

Guest feedback highlights clean and comfortable rooms with a focus on practical amenities such as desks suitable for light office work and well-maintained temperatures indoors. The hotel maintains a smoke-free environment, and although there is no pool or restaurant on-site, it does provide access to a nearby golf course. Reviews praise the friendly and helpful staff, particularly noting their accommodating nature and willingness to provide quiet, peaceful surroundings despite occasional noise issues from neighboring rooms.

Its location offers accessible transportation options, including a 5-minute walk to the metro, facilitating easy exploration of Brooklyn and beyond. Attractions like the Brooklyn Museum, Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and the Brooklyn Bridge are within reach, appealing to travelers interested in arts, nature, and iconic landmarks. Proximity to major airports such as JFK, LaGuardia, and Newark International also adds to its practicality for visitors arriving by air.

The hotel suits guests looking for straightforward, budget-conscious accommodations with attentive service in a residential Brooklyn setting. While some reviews note thin walls and occasional noise disturbances, many appreciate the quietness and safety of the area, making it a reasonable choice for travelers valuing comfort and a genuine neighborhood atmosphere over luxury amenities.

Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.
Facilities & essentials

What's on-site and what you should know before you arrive

The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.

Most popular facilities

Free Wi-Fi
Breakfast
Golf course
Smoke-free

Not available at this property

Parking
Pool
Restaurant
Verified guest reviews

What recent guests are actually saying

Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.

AA
Aleksey Amitai Apr 01, 2026
10

Very nice hotel in it's price range. Location is ok, 5 min walk to metro. Felt safe. Very good service, not something you can find every day in US. Rooms are clean and maintained. When I arrived hotel was fully booked, so I guess only disappointed people leave feedbacks , otherwise I can't explain so few reviews

JO
Jeremy Oquendo Mar 01, 2026
10

Stood here last night, the very kind gentleman named Shanu very accommodating and respectful. He made sure my stay was comfortable and made my checking in easy. He takes his job serious and very genuine about his words. Highly recommend!!

JH
JC Harding Feb 27, 2026
10

Cozy but exceptionally clean establishment. Staff provides friendly & efficient service. Free breakfast was well-prepared and ample for my party of 3. Very limited but safe off-street parking available (recommend early arrival). Definitely a great value for Brooklyn!

DS
Dinesh Singh Feb 15, 2026
10

We stayed here for 2 nights and had a very comfortable stay. The staff here is very warm and helpful and always greet you with a smile. Monica at the front desk was always welcoming of any query and was very helpful in helping us with a late checkout. The team did not crib about extending our hours of checkout and gladly extending the time to help us checkout comfortably. The rooms were comfortable and the property was clean. It has the right amount of furniture including a desk for doing office work. The temperature was maintained well inside the rooms and the water was hot which was very welcome with the chilling weather outside. Overall, I strongly recommend this hotel as a budget option considering its hospitality and great staff.

LC
Laura Clare Feb 15, 2026
10

Loved! Front desk team are lovely, the rooms are amazing and cleaned daily. Safe area, hot breakfast, I can't wait to return My only dislike was the people in the room across from me yelling and speaking loudly and their child who screamed his lungs out for about 3 hours, it was a little stressful, but not the hotels fault at all

E
EIB Jan 07, 2026
10

Front desk staff always giving 5 star service and very understanding even when I had an issue with my card. It's quiet and peaceful and the breakfast staff is excellent. I don't know the reason for low ratings but I've stayed here about 5 times and not a single complaint. Kudos to the team here keep up the excellent work. As for the complaints about the pillows yes they are folded into decorative pillows but once you unfold them they become regular pillows for sleeping.

AW
Alexander Whipp Dec 29, 2025
8.0

I recently stayed at the Best Western Plus hotel in Brooklyn for three days and overall, I had a decent experience. The hotel is perfectly located for a quick tour of Brooklyn and there are plenty of local street parking options nearby if you're willing to look for them. The rooms were clean and well-maintained, which is always a plus. However, I did notice that the walls were quite thin, and I could often hear noises from the neighboring rooms. This may be a concern for light sleepers or those looking for a more peaceful stay. One few small issues I encountered. One was with the pillows. The hotel provides normal pillows, but they are packaged and placed on the bed, which means you have to unpack them yourself. While this is a minor inconvenience, it could be a hassle for some guests. Second the wifi, while free, is spotty and is not protected which could be a concern to patrons. Overall, the Best Western Plus hotel in Brooklyn is a decent option for those looking for a conveniently located, clean, and reasonably priced accommodation. While there are some minor drawbacks such as thin walls and unpacking pillows, I still believe it offers good value for money.

KM
Kathy Mann Dec 27, 2025
8.0

Quiet stay! Room was clean, beds were comfy, staff was nice, breakfast was good. I enjoyed the quiet the most, surprised, because the area is city noisy.

Location & neighborhood

Where you'll find Best Western Plus Brooklyn-Prospect Park

Brooklyn, New York, USA

Diverse, residential area with brick row houses, Victorian homes & laid-back global restaurants.

  • Newkirk Plaza 9 min Walk
  • 18 Ave/Coney Island Av 2 min Walk
  • Coney Island Ave/18 Av 1 min Walk
  • John F. Kennedy International Airport 39 min Car · 1 hr 32 Transit
  • Newark Liberty International Airport 43 min Car · 1 hr 33 Transit
  • LaGuardia Airport 38 min Car · 1 hr 19 Transit
Things to do nearby

Worth the walk or a quick ride

Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in New York. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.

Brooklyn Bridge 91,972 reviews

Brooklyn Bridge

New York, NY 10038, United States

4.8 · Bridge
Brooklyn Museum 10,177 reviews

Brooklyn Museum

200 Eastern Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States

4.7 · Art Museum
Brooklyn Botanic Garden 15,162 reviews

Brooklyn Botanic Garden

Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States

4.7 · Botanical Garden
People also viewed

Similar Hotels in New York

Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.

6401 Bristol Pike, Levittown, PA 19057, United States

Motel 6 Levittown, PA - Bensalem

Stay at Motel 6 Levittown, PA Bensalem, offering free WiFi, parking, and petfriendly rooms 3 miles from Silver Lake Park and 6...

2.6 (563) View
5252 Memorial Dr, The Colony, TX 75056, United States

Tru by Hilton The Colony Dallas

Enjoy a 4.1star stay at Tru by Hilton The Colony Dallas with free WiFi, breakfast, outdoor pool, and close to State Highway 121 ...

4.1 (480) View
17 John St, New York, NY 10038, United States

17John Hotel

Enjoy a 4.4star stay at 17John Hotel in New York City. Accessible rooms with kitchens, free WiFi, near Brooklyn Bridge and 9/11 ...

4.4 (345) View
1750 W Quitman St, Iuka, MS 38852, United States

Iuka Motel

Iuka Motel offers budgetfriendly lodging in Iuka, MS. Rated 2.8/5 with 50 reviews, close to attractions like Woodall Mountain and...

2.8 (50) View
W5930 Duck Point Rd, Tomahawk, WI 54487, United States

Duck Point Resort

Stay at Duck Point Resort in Tomahawk, WI. Enjoy airconditioned, petfriendly rooms with kitchens. Close to Lake Mohawksin and Ce...

3.8 (33) View
15 NW 4th Ave, Portland, OR 97209, United States

The Hoxton, Portland

Stay at The Hoxton, Portland, a 4.3star hotel featuring sophisticated rooms, a rooftop cafe, basement bar, and close to Portland ...

4.3 (1,043) View
911 NE-32, Oakland, NE 68045, United States

Oakland Express Motel

Enjoy free WiFi, parking, and breakfast at Oakland Express Motel in Oakland, NE. Close to Swedish Heritage Center and Summit Lake...

4.3 (43) View
5708 Northampton Blvd, Virginia Beach, VA 23455, United States

Magnuson Hotel Virginia Beach

Magnuson Hotel Virginia Beach offers laidback rooms with private balconies, free WiFi, parking, and breakfast in a quiet residen...

2.8 (1,197) View
701 Convention Center Blvd, New Orleans, LA 70130, United States

The Riverfront Hotel New Orleans

Stay at The Riverfront Hotel New Orleans offering upscale rooms, fitness center, bar, and easy access to the National WWII Museum ...

4.1 (1,943) View
Share your stay

Stayed at Best Western Plus Brooklyn-Prospect Park? Help the next traveler decide.

Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.

Your email is only used to verify the review — it won't be shown publicly.